Turnagain Dental Blog

Custom Mouthguards vs Store-Bought: What Athletes in Anchorage Should Know

Your teeth are not replaceable. A $400 custom mouthguard is the cheapest insurance policy a young athlete can buy.

·5 min read·All Articles

The American Dental Association estimates athletes are 60 times more likely to suffer dental injury when not wearing a mouthguard. In contact sports like hockey, football and lacrosse — and in many non-contact sports like skateboarding and mountain biking — the difference between a knocked-out tooth and a saved one is often a piece of plastic that costs less than a single implant.

Your Three Options

Stock Mouthguards ($5–$15)

Pre-formed, one-size-fits-all. They're bulky, make it hard to breathe and talk, and offer the least protection. Avoid for any serious athlete.

Boil-and-Bite ($15–$40)

You soften them in hot water and bite. Better than stock but still a generic fit — they tend to loosen, especially during long games, and many athletes end up chewing on them.

Custom Mouthguards from Your Dentist ($250–$500)

We take an impression of your teeth and fabricate a guard that fits precisely. Thinner where it doesn't need protection, thicker over molars and impact zones. They stay in place, allow normal breathing and speech, and protect against jaw concussions as well as broken teeth.

Why Fit Matters More Than Thickness

A poorly-fit guard absorbs impact unevenly and can actually transmit force into the jaw joint. A custom guard distributes impact across the entire arch and reduces the risk of concussion by up to 50% in some studies.

When to Replace

  • Every 1–2 years for adults
  • Every season for growing teens — jaws change fast
  • Immediately if torn, perforated or chewed through
  • After any significant impact

Mouthguards for Braces

Orthodontic patients need a guard that accommodates brackets. We fabricate guards with extra clearance and a softer inner lining so they don't catch on wires or hurt your lips during play.

Frequently Asked Questions

Are custom mouthguards worth the cost?

Yes. Replacing a single knocked-out tooth with an implant runs $3,500–$6,000. A custom guard is one of the highest-ROI pieces of athletic equipment you can buy.

Can my child wear a custom guard with braces?

Yes. We make orthodontic-friendly guards designed specifically to fit over brackets without damaging them or your child's lips.

How do I clean a custom mouthguard?

Rinse with cool water after each use. Brush with a soft toothbrush and mild soap (not toothpaste) weekly. Store in a ventilated case — never in a sealed plastic bag.

Does insurance cover custom mouthguards?

Some dental plans cover athletic mouthguards, especially for minors. We verify benefits before fabrication.

Schedule Your Visit

Ready to Meet Dr. Kennedy?

Call or send a message — we'd love to welcome you to Turnagain Dental.